What Are You Looking For? Type Your Search Here

Thursday, 14 March 2013

A Must Read Letter From Michela Wrong - Food For Thought

To be prudent is to be partial

NAIROBI — Over the years I’ve come to view the Kenyan media with a mixture of respect and affection.

In the 1990s, I watched in awe as Kenyan photographers dodged Daniel arap Moi’s club-wielding riot police. When their colleagues in the newsroom exposed financial scandals, ranging from Goldenberg to Anglo Leasing, I pasted their articles into my files. Like the press pack anywhere, Kenyan journalists liked their beer and could wolf down a buffet in a heartbeat, and the odd brown envelope definitely changed hands. But they were brave. “The best press in Africa,” I told anyone who cared to listen.

So Kenya’s recent election has been a baffling, frustrating time.

In the last few weeks, Western journalists — myself included — have become pariahs, lambasted by Kenya’s twitterati and Facebook users for our coverage and threatened by the government with deportation.

The fury seems exaggerated, given the relative rarity of offending articles. Western reports have attracted undue interest, I’m convinced, because domestic coverage, while increasingly slick, has been so lifeless. It sometimes feels as though a zombie army has taken up position where Kenya’s feisty media used to be, with local reporters going glaze-eyed through the motions.

This malaise was most obvious last week during briefings by the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission at the tallying center in Bomas, just outside Nairobi, when what had been billed as a high-tech, tamper-proof election began to unravel spectacularly. The Kenyan media of old would have gone for the jugular. But when the commission chairman, Issack Hassan, after describing yet another puzzling technical glitch or mysterious delay, asked, “Any questions?” the response was stunned silence.

It was the same when independent election monitors announced their findings. Given just how many anomalies were surfacing, the upbeat assessments of observers from the African Union, the European Union and the Commonwealth seemed inexcusably complacent. Yet once again, Kenyan journalists left most of the questions to their Western counterparts.

Lethargy should not be mistaken for laziness. Yes, rumors are swirling about payoffs and conflicts of interest. But this professional surrender, ironically, appears to stem from the very best of intentions.

During the violence that followed the 2007 election, when militias burned families out of their houses and executed members of rival ethnic communities, Kenya’s media played a not-entirely-innocent role. Hate speech spread by vernacular radio stations and via SMS egged on the men with machetes, just as they once had in Rwanda. One of the three indictees facing trial before the International Criminal Court in The Hague is Joshua arap Sang, who ran the Kalenjin-language radio station Kass FM.

Chastened by that experience, media executives reached a gentlemen’s agreement to avoid anything that might whip up ethnic tensions ahead of this year’s election. There would be no live coverage of announcements or press conferences by political parties.

“Last time,” the media “were part of the problem,” a Kenyan broadcaster told me. “They were corrupted; they were irresponsible. So this time there was a feeling that we had to keep everyone calm, at the expense, if necessary, of our liberties.”

But self-censorship comes at a price: political impartiality. The decision not to inflame ethnic passions meant that media coverage shifted in favor of whoever took an early lead, in this case Uhuru Kenyatta.

Hours after the CORD alliance of the opposition leader Raila Odinga announced that it wanted the tallying of ballots stopped and an audit conducted, Kenyan radio D.J.’s were still cheerfully assuring listeners that everything was on track. That may have prevented passions in Odinga’s Luo community from exploding, but it was a massive distortion of the truth.

The local media swiftly fell into the habit of brushing off CORD’s declarations. Television broadcasts of Odinga’s announcement that he would challenge the outcome of the election before the Supreme Court switched to Uhuru’s acceptance speech before the Q. and A. with Odinga had even begun. By this Wednesday, Kenya’s largest newspaper devoted more space to the selection of a new pope than to the lawsuits being prepared by CORD and civil society groups.

The Kenyan media’s self-restraint reveals a society terrified by its own capacity for violence. “What maturity is this that trembles at the first sign of disagreement or challenge?” asked the Kenyan cartoonist Patrick Gathara in a superb blog post, citing a national “peace lobotomy.” He went on: “What peace lives in the perpetual shadow of a self-annihilating violence?”

Shortly before handing Uhuru his winner’s certificate, the chairman of the election commission congratulated the Kenyan media on their “exemplary behavior.” As he did, the screen above his head was showing figures that did not add up.

Any journalist worth their salt should start feeling itchy when praised by those in authority. The recent accolades will chafe as more polling irregularities become public. The media should be asking themselves whether, in their determination to act responsibly, they allowed another major abuse to occur right before their eyes.

Michela Wrong has covered Africa for nearly two decades, reporting for Reuters, the BBC and The Financial Times. She is the author of “It’s Our Turn to Eat: The Story of a Kenyan Whistleblower.”

No comments:

Post a Comment

News Categories

Latest Kenyan News Shocking News Celebrity News Lifestyle News National News Big Brother Africa Rt. Hon. Raila Amollo Odinga Sports The Chase World News Breaking News Kenya Hon. Uhuru Kenyatta People's Opinion and Views CORD Latest News CORD Politics RIP Hon Mutula Kilonzo Kethi Kilonzo Motivational Mutula Kilonzo From The Kenyan Courts Kenya Drama Festivals JUBILEE ICC Suspects Kenya Mourns Mutula Kilonzo ODM Politics Breaking News From The Supreme Court IEBC Kenyan Elections 2013 Mombasa News The Jubilee Cabinet Secretaries Business News International News The Jubilee Cabinet The New Kenyan Cabinet Warning Hon. Stephen Kalonzo Musyoka Huddah Monroe Kenyan Mentors Nairobi Politics The New Kenyan Cabinet Secretaries Banking Jobs Barrack Obama Director Jobs Dr. Evans Odhiambo Kidero International News and Politics Jubilee Politics Kenyan Condolences Kenyan Politics Manager Job Positions National Security Propaganda The HIV Fight Arsenal Football Club Brazil 2014 Business Resources Churchil Show County Politics Food For Thought Hon. Moses Wetangula Hon. William Ruto Jaguar Kenyan Mourns Local Media and Entertainment News From Counties Sad News TNA Politics The Late Hon Mutula Kilonzo Uhuru Kenyatta's Cabinet Uhuru Kenyatta's New Look Cabinet World Cup World Events Ann Mbaru Business Reviews Daniel Owira Education News Encouragement English Premier League Eunice Nthenya From The Rest of The World Gadgets Health News Innternational News Insurance Jobs Just For Laughs Kenya National Examination Council Latest News From The Kenyan Supreme Court Media and Journalism Jobs Miguna Miguna Mike Mbuvi Sonko Nairobi County Nairobi County News Peoples Opinion Picture Speak Resources Rumours Sales and Marketing Jobs Team Leaders Jobs Technology The Forth President Of The Republic Of Kenya The Otonglo Boy Wayne Rooney #Occupy Parliament 14TH March A Must Read Accounting and Finance Jobs Aden Duale Africa's Greatest Alfred Mutua Ali Hassa Joho Ali Hassan America Mourns Arts and Drama Business Administration Jobs Call Center and BPO Jobs Chief Justice Willy Mutunga Christine Khasinah-Odero Communication Skills Computers Corruption Customer Service Jobs David Moyes Decision 2013 EAC News East African News Elections2017 Entertainment and Showbiz Financial Institution Jobs Forbes List Francis Kimemia From The Kenyan Hospitals From The Pulpit Funny Moments Germany Football Team Groove Awards Kenya Help Corner Human Resources Jobs IT Jobs Imperial Bank Group Insecurity Insurance Claims Jobs and Employment Opportunities Joho Joho's Woes Julie Gichuru KANU Politics KCPE 2014 Results KCPE 2016 Results KCPE News Kenya Labour Day Celebrations Kenyan 2013 Disputed Presidential Election Kenyan Blogs Kenyan Media Kenyan's Speak Kidero's Cabinet Koigi Wa Wamwere Larry Madowo Law Enforcement Jobs Legal Jobs London Meet Margaret Kenyatta Margaret Wambui Media and Arts Mombasa Governor Musalia Mudavadi Music Mutula Kilonzo Jnr Nairobi Governor Nairobi Senate Nasa Politics Nelson Mandela Neymar Personal Advise Peter Nduati Planning and Logistics Jobs Pokello Nare Praise and Worship President Uhuru Kenyatta Product Reviews Relationship Management Jobs Reports and Analysis Resolution Insurance Sabasaba Sacco Jobs Speeches Surveying Jobs Technician Jobs The Governor Seat The Talking Point Thiago Silva Tragic News UDF Politica URP Politics Ugandan Celebrities Uhuru Kenyata in UK Valentine Day Who Killed Mutula Kilonzo Who is Who in Kenya